October 17 blog post on school philosophies
Democratic schools
I had never heard of this method of schooling. I have heard of Classical schooling which is at the complete other end of the academic spectrum. I was not aware of the existence of Sudbury Valley School in Sudbury, Ma, which is right by my area of residence. After reading about the school I was surprised to see how much power the students exert on their learning trajectory. Are they learning? What are they learning? are some of the questions I would ask. I don't agree with the idea that there is no structure to the day. I feel that everybody needs a structure in their days, especially the young and the adolescents. I have not seen any research that validates the benefits of the democratic schools. Do the students pursue higher education? It seems to be an alternative form of education for students who have unresolved struggles and challenges in traditional schools. This would not have been a choice of school for my children to attend.
Flipped Classroom
I am not sure I agree with this model for young students. I feel it is important to have learning centers in the classrooms where explorations, discussions and deep thinking happen. The children learn various skills that are foundations for executive functioning. It seems to me that there is a lot of screen time, technology used in the flipped classroom, and the foundational skills cannot be taught through technology. Using modeling, sensory skills and muscle memory to learn and remember is what develops the brain, while just learning from technology is not sufficient for better and deeper learning.
I have taken several online courses with forums where teaching, reading, and discussions were used. I can say that sometimes I did fall behind because the courses were self-paced. Yet as an adult I can manage to rearrange my schedule and catch up. Can the yount students handle prioritizing? I honestly don’t think so since they have not built the necessary skills yet.
As for choosing flipped classroom for my children I would not take the option. I felt that my children became better students and learned more in the classroom with the immediate and personal interactions with peers and instructors.
Montessori Education
During the last several years I have gained a lot of knowledge regarding Montessori schools and the system. I like Maria Montessori’s philosophy on education. As the children develop psychological self-construction they are engaging by freely choosing and acting in an environment that is constructed for optimal development.
Maria Montessori’s belief in education plays a role in developing world peace and the curriculum for Five Great Lessons. They are still part of the Montessori schooling as I found out this weekend by talking to a few Montessori teachers at a workshop. The teachers stated that some schools are more lenient with the philosophy than others. Also, the training of the teachers is exclusive for Montessori schools and the Master’s Degree that they get (if chosen) is not accepted in any other schooling system.
I have had the pleasure of meeting some alumni from Montessori schools. The shared experiences had pros and cons depending on the person. The challenge for several of the students was to fit in the society. The reason was that the world is not a Montessori world.
This would not have been a choice of school for my children.
Waldorf Education
I have heard about Waldorf Schools. In fact there are three in my neck of the woods. It is important that the Waldorf schools are putting high emphasis on education without forcing the students and are tying the beauty of arts and crafts with education. Yet, reality of life is not pretty. The fact that many serious issues, like vaccinations, racial issues, bullying, are not being faced, discussed, challenged and taught. These are just as important as content subjects and cannot be covered up with the prettiness of arts. There should be a balance in education where all aspects of life are addressed.
Glen Urquhart School
I would drive by the school several times a week and always wondered what kind of school it was. Finally, I stopped one day and inquired. Ironically, now I read about it. It is nature based which I think is perfect for preschoolers. The encouragement of an environment where children explore, think, discuss and learn is important for me. I liked the fact that it involves the community and is ethnically and culturally diverse. Communication, effective collaboration, problem solving and responsibility /accountablity are all parts of the building blocks in early childhood. I would have chosen this preschool for my children if it was availble
Classical Schools
I learned a lot about classical school when I met two of my daughter’s friends who had attended Classical students - one in upstate New York, and one in California. The classical schools have a long tradition where students are taught to seek the truth, seek goodness and see beauty through the study of liberal arts. The liberal arts are grammar, logic, rhetoric, arithmatic, geometry, music, astronomy, and of course Latin.
The Classical approach of education teaches students how to learn and how to think. The approach is how and when students are taught. They learn in three stages - grammar, logic, and rhetoric - also known as trivium. The first stage grammar (K-6) is where things are taught through songs, chants and rhymes. Usually, they stay with us throughout our lives. The logic stage (grades 7-9) is the teenage years. Teens are generally argumentative in this stage, so the learning is done through reasoning, informal and formal logic and how to argue with wisdom and eloquence. In rhetoric stage (grades 10-12) students become independent thinkers and communicators. They study and practice rhetoric-persuasive speaking and effective writing. Classical schools have produced many scholars, musicians, lawyers, philosophers, and artists.
It diminished in 1900, when progressive education took over. Now this method of schooling is widely used by homeschoolers and k-12 system is being reviewed, renewed and expanded to be used again. I would have used this method of schooling for my children if it was available to me.
Pedagogy of the Oppressed
This was very confusing to read. My take was that the author is insisting on equal education for all. His philosophy is based on the socialis theorists that life should be equal for everybody. Thus education should be free and equal, and available to all. On the other hand he is emphasizing the importance of open dialogues and mutual learning. He feels that everyone can learn given the right platform.
My initial schooling was in a socialist system, where the environment was very totalitarian. The teacher was the “banker” and the students were the “empty vessels.” A lot of content at high levels was introduced without collaboration, mutual learning or discussions. The teacher was the law. I am sure the schooling system is changed now and the teachers and students are more open to team work, discussions and deeper level of thinking.
Even if I still lived in Armenia, I think my children would have been exposed to a different style of education.
Comments
Post a Comment